FiringSquad: Home of the Hardcore Gamer - Games, Hardware, Reviews and NewsSubmit your own or view users' CPU overclocking results!

  
 Home   News   THE MATRIX   Deals   Hardware   Games   Features   Media   Products   Forums   FS China 
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Home : Hardware : Sound Cards : Battle of the Gaming Audio Titans: Creative Labs vs. NVIDIA
» Join the Greatest Gaming Community NOW! (It's free)

Already a member? Login
 



Random Gallery >> 
Click to view high-res Image!
Sleeping Dogs (formerly True Crime: Hong Kong) Screenshots [14] (0)

[FX] 3-Screen Effect - Guide (part-4) (0) by nGAGE
CRANG That S#!T Up! (15) by ElwinRansom
My First Entry For Crank That S#!T Up! (2) by deathknight.92
[FX] 3-Screen Effect - Guide (part-1) (0) by nGAGE
Whoz's Cranking that S#!T (13) by whozthisguy
The Nvidia "Crank That S#!T Up" Quiz Show, Part 2 (6) by mohawkade
My Crank That Sh#!t Up! entry :D (3) by chipmunk995
HOW I CRANK THAT S#!T UP!! (4) by nvidia4life
Nvidia+Socom Cranks that $#%^ UP!!!!! (4) by mrinfinit3
Crank It Up! (11) by Kilos

More Blogs >>




Battle of the Gaming Audio Titans: Creative Labs vs. NVIDIA
January 14, 2003   Alan Dang > [View My Other Articles]
Product Info | User Reviews | Article Images(10) | Image Gallery | Comments | Forum Thread
Audio Fidelity/Performance


Again, we did not have our professional recording card on hand and so these numbers should be taken as relative indicators of performance.

Analog Performance (16-bit/48 kHz)

The Audigy 2’s analog input appeared to roll off the high frequencies significantly and so we opted to use our DigiFire 7.1 to measure the frequency response. Note this graph measuring the Audigy 2 Output, as you can see the Audigy 2 Line-In rolls off the high end significantly:

Battle of the Gaming Audio Titans:  Creative Labs vs. NVIDIA [  @ 512 x 319 ] > View Full-Size in another window.



Here are the results you should really be looking at:

Frequency Response

Battle of the Gaming Audio Titans:  Creative Labs vs. NVIDIA [  @ 512 x 319 ] > View Full-Size in another window.



Noise Level

Battle of the Gaming Audio Titans:  Creative Labs vs. NVIDIA [  @ 512 x 319 ] > View Full-Size in another window.



Dynamic Range

Battle of the Gaming Audio Titans:  Creative Labs vs. NVIDIA [  @ 512 x 319 ] > View Full-Size in another window.



THD + Noise (-3 dB FS)

Battle of the Gaming Audio Titans:  Creative Labs vs. NVIDIA [  @ 512 x 319 ] > View Full-Size in another window.



Intermodulation Distortion

Battle of the Gaming Audio Titans:  Creative Labs vs. NVIDIA [  @ 512 x 319 ] > View Full-Size in another window.



Stereo Crosstalk

Battle of the Gaming Audio Titans:  Creative Labs vs. NVIDIA [  @ 512 x 319 ] > View Full-Size in another window.



Digital Performance (16-bit/48 kHz)


There is a significant ripple at the upper frequencies when using the Audigy 2’s SPDIF input. This doesn’t occur when we use the SPDIF IN of the Philips Acoustic Edge. This shows that the digital input of the Audigy 2 is poor and thus our 16-bit/48-kHz SPDIF measurements are done with the Philips Acoustic Edge input.

Battle of the Gaming Audio Titans:  Creative Labs vs. NVIDIA [  @ 512 x 319 ] > View Full-Size in another window.



We get equally interesting results when we compare the SPDIF output. We can see that the nForce2 rolls off its bass significantly. The Philips Acoustic Edge has the best digital output.

Battle of the Gaming Audio Titans:  Creative Labs vs. NVIDIA [  @ 512 x 319 ] > View Full-Size in another window.


Battle of the Gaming Audio Titans:  Creative Labs vs. NVIDIA [  @ 512 x 319 ] > View Full-Size in another window.



Test

Audigy 2 SPDIF 16/48

nForce2 SPDIF 16/48

Philips PSC706 SPDIF 16/48

Frequency response (from 40 Hz to 15 kHz), dB: +0.00, -0.00 +0.01, -0.26 +0.00, -0.00
Noise level, dB (A): -97.2 -98.1 -101.7
Dynamic range, dB (A): 93.5 95.8 91.7
THD, %: 0.0041 0.0021 0.0021
IMD, %: 0.0095 0.0068 0.0083
Stereo crosstalk, dB: -88.9 -93.1 -96.2

Neither the Audigy 2 nor the nForce2 provides native 44.1 kHz digital output.

Audigy 2 Digital Performance (24-bit/96 kHz)

Test

TOSLINK 24/96

Coax 24/96

Frequency response (from 40 Hz to 15 kHz), dB: +0.00, -0.00 +0.00, -0.00
Noise level, dB (A): -100.9 -101
Dynamic range, dB (A): 98.5 98.5
THD, %: 0.0003 0.0003
IMD, %: 0.0038 0.0039
Stereo crosstalk, dB: -95.3 -93.2



Back! Audio Performance     nForce2: The Good Next!
Blog + Share: Digg Del.icio.us Reddit SU furl • More: AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Send This Article to a Friend!  
Table of Contents
  Print Entire Article  

MATRIX CONTENT » RANDOM MEDIA BLOG More Blogs >>
No ratings yet
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» My Entry for the Crank that SH#!T Up Contest (12)
by TheGamesHD (12) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Posted 19 months ago


 Hottest Topics
Blizzard appealing to block Valve trademarking DOTA (10)
Obsidian has 'Kickstarter fever', asks for suggestions (6)
Skyrim mod toolkit and Steam Workshop integration arrive with free official high-resolution texture pack (6)
Diablo 3 dev diary explains nightmare mode difficulty (5)
Bethesda shows modders how it's done: see what Skyrim developers added during free-form 'Game Jam' week (5)
Today's News >>
Today's Siteseeing >>


 Table of Contents


 Random Thought
If you’re only interested in 2 channel SPDIF output, and don’t care about CPU utilization, the Acoustic Edge is a strong contender.

FiringSquad is powered by... Back to Top Site MapContact UsAdvertise With Us Privacy StatementAbout Us  
News RSSSiteseeing RSSArticle RSS   © 1998-2012 FS Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved