FiringSquad: Home of the Hardcore Gamer - Games, Hardware, Reviews and NewsSubmit your own or view users' CPU overclocking results!

  
 Home   News   THE MATRIX   Deals   Hardware   Games   Features   Media   Products   Forums   FS China 
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Home : Hardware : Video Cards : GeForce FX 5900 XT Shootout
» Join the Greatest Gaming Community NOW! (It's free)

Already a member? Login
 


C&C:Renegade Review, wrist-slittingly good! (8) by McStu
How to Overclock Guide (2) by SuperCharge
An EVGA Collage (0) by Samuel71
Overclocking: The Basics (2) by slugbug
Guitar Hero 3 - The thing that should not be (UPDATED) (5) by Beefysworld
Guide to Overclocking: OC Juice and Overclocking Your Way to Become a Better Person (1) by jarrodthome
Far Cry 2 SP Review (wip) (1) by jacobvandy
Half Life 2 (Round 2) *runs* (8) by exe3
My eVGA ride (0) by devit
FTW! (0) by Gh3tTo5oLdIeR

More Blogs >>


 Hottest Topics
Blizzard statement on StarCraft II LAN (17)
StarCraft II lacks LAN support (13)
Wolfenstein system requirements released (11)
Street Fighter IV PC hits Steam (9)
Xbox 360/PS3 price cuts coming? (8)
Microsoft sued over Xbox LIVE (7)
Most users ignore routine computer maintenance (7)
ASUS 24" monitor for $169.99 shipped (7)
PS3 Slim production slated to begin this month (7)
100 million used games traded each year in US (7)
AMD sheds more light on TWKR CPUs (7)
Firefox 3.5 released (6)
Mozilla working to fix bugs w/Firefox 3.5 (6)
Tekken boss says unlockables are 'outdated' (5)
Rumor: Sony prepping PSP with phone capabilities (5)
Today's News >>
Today's Siteseeing >>


 News Archive
This Month

June 1 - 30, 2009

May 1 - 31, 2009

April 1 - 30, 2009

March 1 - 31, 2009

February 1 - 28, 2009

January 1 - 31, 2009

December 1 - 31, 2008

November 1 - 30, 2008

October 1 - 31, 2008

September 1 - 30, 2008

August 1 - 31, 2008

July 1 - 31, 2008



GeForce FX 5900 XT Shootout
March 01, 2004   Brandon Sandman Bell > [View My Other Articles]
Product Info | User Reviews | Article Images(28) | Image Gallery | Comments | Forum Thread
Conclusion


While we normally like to declare a winner in our shootout comparison articles, it’s just too difficult to pick one this time. All of the cards we’ve presented today are designed to appeal in different ways, with the ultimate winner depending on your tastes and preferences.

Chaintech’s SA5900X has been designed to appeal to the consumer who wants all-out cooling. The board sports a cooler with a copper core, while its fan operates at the same (higher) RPMs at all times, regardless of which mode the board is currently operating in. This is great if you’re a hardcore gamer, especially if you’re overclocking, you always know that regardless of the situation, your card’s fan is working overtime to keep its NV35 graphics core cool. But what if you spend most of your time at the desktop browsing webpages? In this case, you may want something a little quieter.

MSI’s GeForce FX 5900 XT card, the FX5900XT-VTD128, is the exact opposite. It’s T.O.P. Tech Cooler was the quietest solution in this roundup, and was drowned out by the sound of our Thermaltake Silent Boost K8, which is one of the quieter Athlon 64 coolers on the market. It operates at the same low level of RPMs (we’d estimate somewhere between 2,000-3,000 RPMs) regardless of mode, making it perfect for those of you who want to build a near silent PC. It also boasts video input for those of you who would like to make your own home movies. This feature in particular is extremely hard to find among GeForce FX 5900 XT cards. Its only real weakness is the lack of built-in hardware monitoring.

The Leadtek board presents an interesting contrast in the sense that it does boast hardware monitoring functionality, as well as its WinFox hardware monitoring/overclocking tool, but the card lacks the exotic copper coolers present on the cards from Chaintech and Gigabyte. In operation, we did find that their Air Surround cooling solution ran quieter than the eVGA and Chaintech coolers, and largely mirrored the performance of the Chaintech cooler at stock speeds. In addition, the 2.2ns memory modules our board shipped with allowed us to overclock the board’s memory to unprecedented levels for a GeForce FX 5900 XT card. If this is important to you, you may want to check with your preferred retailer to see if their Leadtek boards use the same Hynix modules (it would certainly explain the higher price these boards tend to go for) our card shipped with. It’s also possible that Leadtek ran a batch of boards with 2.2ns memory modules because it was all they had on hand at the time.

Gigabyte’s cooler is copper-based for better heat transfer, and quieter than the eVGA and Chaintech cards, making it a worthy competitor as well. Gigabyte also has one of the better software bundles (although admittedly, this is subjective). Their V-Tuner software can also be used to overclock your graphics card, but unfortunately the board doesn’t offer hardware monitoring capabilities.

eVGA’s e-GeForce FX 5900 SE is one of the least expensive GeForce FX 5900 XT graphics cards on the market, and is a good all-round performer. It doesn’t offer some of the dazzling features of the other boards like copper cooling or hardware monitoring, but it is easy to find and was incredibly popular when it first came out thanks to the Call of Duty bundle all cards shipped with. As a first generation board design it has since faded away from the limelight a little, but it’s still a solid card that’s worthy of consideration.

In any case, NVIDIA’s GeForce FX 5900 XT core has been popular since its inception due to its attractive pricing and good performance in today’s titles. NVIDIA has certainly delivered a card that has given the mainstream market what it wanted, a graphics solution that offers all the features of the flagship cards and much of the performance, but at a price point that is much more attractive to the wallet. The GeForce FX 5900 XT is one of the best bargains on the graphics market right now, and is truly a worthy successor to GeForce4 Ti 4200.



Back! Overclocking     Back to FS frontpage
Blog + Share: Digg Del.icio.us Reddit SU furl • More: AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Send This Article to a Friend!  
Table of Contents
  Print Entire Article  

MATRIX CONTENT » RANDOM MEDIA BLOG More Blogs >>
No ratings yet
» Please rate this
I am an AMD AgentRead this Media-Blog entry!» »» best haiku ever (0)
by darkportal_4 (57) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Posted 2 months ago
  Latest Content
3D Performance with ARMA II Demo
3D Performance with ARMA II Demo
Wondering which video cards perform best with ARMA II? Wonder no more. In this article we've combined GPUs ranging from the Radeon 3870 up to the GeForce GTX 295 across two different CPUs: a Core i7-965 Extreme Edition, and a Core 2 Quad Q8400. See how well the game scales across the various GPUs and CPUs inside!
Jul 3, 2009   [ View Similar Articles | View Comments ]
ASUS Crosshair III Formula Review
ASUS Crosshair III Formula Review
With its $200 price tag, ASUS' latest Republic of Gamers board is designed to appeal to AMD enthusiasts looking for the best without busting your bank account. And thanks its dazzling array of LEDs, good cooling, and SupremeFX X-Fi audio, it's pretty feature-packed. Is it worth the premium ASUS charges though? See how it stacks up against the competition in our latest review!
Jun 25, 2009   [ View Similar Articles | View Comments ]
Sapphire Toxic HD 4890 Review
Editor's Choice Award Sapphire Toxic HD 4890 Review
With a beefier power subsystem, OC'ed clocks, and custom vapor chamber cooling, Sapphire's Toxic HD 4890 takes ATI's Radeon 4890 GPU to another level. In fact the card delivers performance rivaling the GTX 285 in some cases. But is it worth the price premium? Find out in today's review!
Jun 18, 2009   [ View Similar Articles | View Comments ]
Gigabyte AM3 Motherboard Roundup
Gigabyte AM3 Motherboard Roundup
Whether you've got $80 to spend on a new AM3 motherboard, or $180, Gigabyte's got you covered. In today's article we take a look at Gigabyte's high-end and low-end AM3 offerings and find a lot to like. See how the board's compare to one another and perform inside!
Jun 15, 2009   [ View Similar Articles | View Comments ]
Intel Core i7-975 Extreme Edition/Core i7-950 Performance Preview
Intel Core i7-975 Extreme Edition/Core i7-950 Performance Preview
Armed with higher clock speeds and a new D0 stepping designed to deliver improved OC'ing headroom, we were eager to see how far we could push Intel's latest flagship processor, the Core i7-975 Extreme Edition, and it didn't disappoint. See what happens when the 4GHz mark is easily shattered in this article!
Jun 2, 2009   [ View Similar Articles | View Comments ]
AMD Phenom II X2 550 Black Edition/Athlon II X2 250 Performance Preview
AMD Phenom II X2 550 Black Edition/Athlon II X2 250 Performance Preview
Packing two processing cores, 6MB of L3 cache, an unlocked multiplier, and a 3.1GHz clock speed, AMD's Phenom II X2 550 Black is targeted towards enthusiasts looking to OC. Its $102 price tag is inexpensive too. But is it a worthy competitor to Core 2 Duo? AMD's also unleashing a new Athlon II CPU today. See how both new AMD CPUs perform against the competition from Intel inside!
Jun 1, 2009   [ View Similar Articles | View Comments ]
Logitech G19 Gaming Keyboard Review
Logitech G19 Gaming Keyboard Review
Sporting a larger, higher resolution color LCD, configurable backlit keys, and reconfigured G-keys, Logitech's G19 offers a host of improvements over its predecessor, the G15. But is it worthy of its lofty price tag? Decide for yourself in our review!
Jun 1, 2009   [ View Similar Articles | View Comments ]
Gigabyte GV-N275UD-896H GeForce GTX 275 Review
Gigabyte GV-N275UD-896H GeForce GTX 275 Review
With its 2-ounce copper PCB and 1200MHz memory, Gigabyte's GV-N275UD-896H is one of the first GeForce GTX 275 cards on the market to deviate from NVIDIA's reference design. See how it compares to the stock GTX 275 in today's review!
May 27, 2009   [ View Similar Articles | View Comments ]
ASUS W90Vp Review
Editor's Choice Award ASUS W90Vp Review
With two Mobility Radeon 4870 GPUs, dual 7200 RPM hard drives, an 18.4" 1080p display, and 2.8GHz Core 2 CPU, the ASUS W90Pv packs more horsepower than most desktop PCs. Remarkably of all though the system retails for $2199-$2499 depending on the SKU. Is this really the ultimate gaming notebook? Find out in today's review!
May 20, 2009   [ View Similar Articles | View Comments ]
ASUS ENGTX260 Matrix Quick Take Review
Editor's Choice Award ASUS ENGTX260 Matrix Quick Take Review
With its dual-slot cooler and support for voltage adjustment, we mananged to crank ASUS' excellent ENGTX260 Matrix to speeds we've never seen from a GTX 260 card before. In fact, once OC'ed the card outran the GTX285! Read on for the full details!
May 13, 2009   [ View Similar Articles | View Comments ]




 Hottest Topics
Blizzard statement on StarCraft II LAN (17)
StarCraft II lacks LAN support (13)
Wolfenstein system requirements released (11)
Street Fighter IV PC hits Steam (9)
Xbox 360/PS3 price cuts coming? (8)
Today's News >>
Today's Siteseeing >>


 Table of Contents


 Talk Back
Which GeForce FX 5900 XT board one the comparison in your eyes? Are you surprised so few boards offer hardware-monitoring support? Voice your thoughts in the news comments!

Check Out These Related Articles >>
3D Performance with ARMA II Demo
3D Performance with ARMA II Demo
Sapphire Toxic HD 4890 Review
Sapphire Toxic HD 4890 Review
Gigabyte GV-N275UD-896H GeForce GTX 275 Review
Gigabyte GV-N275UD-896H GeForce GTX 275 Review
ASUS ENGTX260 Matrix Quick Take Review
ASUS ENGTX260 Matrix Quick Take Review
MSI N285GTX GeForce GTX 285 SuperPipe OC Review
MSI N285GTX GeForce GTX 285 SuperPipe OC Review
Gigabyte GV-N96TZL-1GI GeForce 9600 GT Quick Take Review
Gigabyte GV-N96TZL-1GI GeForce 9600 GT Quick Take Review
ATI Radeon 4770 Performance Preview
ATI Radeon 4770 Performance Preview
FiringSquad is powered by... Back to Top Site MapContact UsAdvertise With Us Privacy StatementAbout Us  
News RSSSiteseeing RSSArticle RSS   © 1998-2009 FS Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved