FiringSquad: Home of the Hardcore Gamer - Games, Hardware, Reviews and NewsSubmit your own or view users' CPU overclocking results!

  
 Home   News   THE MATRIX   Deals   Hardware   Games   Features   Media   Products   Forums   FS China 
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Home : Matrix : Clusters : Editors Challenge Sponsored by Intel Round 2
» Join the Greatest Gaming Community NOW! (It's free)

Already a member? Login
 

  Cluster Page All Clusters Matrix Home
Editors Challenge Sponsored by Intel Round 2
Number of members: 29
Created: 75 months ago by Dant (697) My Xfire username is: wanchaiwarrior Talk with this user on their Shout Box
Permanent Link:

Time to Step things up.
Posted 75 months ago

Round 2 Rules

What a fantastic turn out. Clearly we have had some of the best content anywhere on the web since this contest started. If there was a way for FiringSquad to hire all 30 of the qualifiers, we would surely do it.

You have all read the results so far. The people to beat at this point in this competition are:
From Prelim 1:
Millroy: Dear Star Trek: Legacy (for the PC)
jacobvandy: Windows Vista: The Future of PC Gaming (Part 1)
Suibhne: Review: Dark Messiah of Might & Magic (single player)
From Prelim 2:
Power666: The CPU and GPU engaged for marriage
darrellwu: Graphics: Style and Photorealism
dasickninja: Bigfoot Killer NIC Review.

Some of you didn't qualify in the first preliminary but came back in the second and really stepped up the pace. So don't be discouraged if you are not at the top of the list at the moment. Remember that each article will be based on its own merit. You've made it this far which proves you have the talent.

Now for the rules.
In this round you are going to have to convince us that you really know what you are talking about. Your mblog can't be an editorial piece. It can not be a fluff piece. In this round your review must combine both hardware and a game. We will allow any combination of any device provided that it is gaming related with any game that you play (Whoopass Soda is not a gaming device). As an example, you can discuss how different video cards affect the frame rates of a specific game. Or, you can discuss how different game settings affect network game play or playability based on video resolution. Part of the judges job will be to judge how pertinent your argument is to the game and hardware in question and will rate you on this relevance along with your score for writing style, accuracy, and entertainment value.

You must also include at least 3 images in your mblog that support your argument.

You may also include video capture to support your argument, although it will only have a very small influence on the judges scores (5 points max per judge out of 100 possible points). It might however have a bigger impact on the FiringSquad readers scores (still worth 300 out of a possible 700 points).

You are only allowed to submit one mblog for this round. The sooner you submit, the more page views and votes you will receive. Remember to use a pertinent and catchy title. This can have a HUGE impact on page views as we have seen from previous rounds. It might not hurt to read up on search engine optimization (SEO) and how you can drive traffic to your article. Paid advertising will get you disqualified.

If you need help or want some feedback from the editors, you'll need to email us no later than Friday March 9th to fs.feedback@firingsquad.com. We will attempt to get as much feedback to you as possible as quickly as possible.

To summarize:
No editorials.
Must include affects of hardware on game or vice-versa.
One mblog per participant.
Minimum 3 images to support your opinion.
Video capture optional (small point advantage given if effective).
Help available if requested before Friday March 9th.
Submissions start Wednesday March 7th.
Submissions close midnight Wednesday March 14th.
Top 10 qualifiers move to the next round.

Do not hesitate to post in the comments section of this cluster if you have general questions.

Finally, we wish you the best of luck and look forward to reading your excellent submissions.

ACTIONS
- You cannot join this cluster at this time


          CLUSTER MEDIA-BLOGS
 
24 Entries  
69.4% 16 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» Wii Remote: the PC revolution? (7)
by Power666 (25) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
75% 20 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» The Greatest Game You've Never Played: Allegiance's R3 release. (18)
by darrellwu (24) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
60.6% 17 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» Putting you in the game (4)
by Itchyeyes (77) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
85.2% 56 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» Help My FPS Has Fallen and I Can’t Get Up! (17)
by p4l1ndr0m3 (499) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
52.9% 7 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» Apples to Oranges, or, Does the Wii Remote Outperform the GCN Controller in Dragon Ball Z: Budokai Tenkaichi 2? (3)
by evernight (6) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
71.6% 19 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» Stranger in a Strange Land (8)
by suibhne (65) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
77.7% 30 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» 3rd PARTY OPTIMIZED, ATI DRIVER ROUNDUP (41)
by kevinSpiess (156) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
67.8% 18 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» The Novint Falcon: 3D Tactile-feedback Input (4)
by Kristopher (5) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
72.9% 14 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» Playing your G5 to the Max! (16)
by Droniac (114) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
70% 16 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» Xbox 360 Wireless Racing Wheel - Drive away today, no strings (wires) attached! (11)
by Beefysworld (290) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
74.8% 21 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» What to know about a MOMO (or any other good wheel for that matter): The Force is in the Feedback (10)
by Millroy (24) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
75% 22 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» Project Gotham Racing 3 Enlivened with the Xbox360 Wireless Racing Wheel (21)
by OldFriend (178) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
71.8% 22 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» Carpal Tunnel Gaming: The Natural Wireless Laser Mouse 6000 (18)
by obsolete (29) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
64.1% 17 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» Does this resolution make me look fat? (10)
by Swatt (25) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
49.1% 11 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» Evolution of a Game Engine: from RTS to FPS (17)
by Mishkin (30) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
71.4% 22 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» Let the Games Begin: Vista,XP and Your Hardware (9)
by rados (15) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
22.5% 16 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» Sadistic, Psychotic, Homocidal Little Girls (13)
by quixilver (5) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
74.8% 29 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» Design Your Own Online Roleplaying Universe (8)
by chentsen (41) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
75.3% 32 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» Portable Next-Gen Gaming - Review: HP nc8430 Notebook PC (13)
by xens (11) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
64.2% 24 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» Windows Vista: The Future of PC Gaming (Part Two) (19)
by jacobvandy (1636) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
74.8% 27 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» Lord of the Rings Online: Shadows of Angmar - NVIDIA 6800 Guide (24)
by indigo196 (258) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
79.1% 55 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» Your Hard Drive's Kung-fu is Weak! (37)
by CanadaDave (303) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
70% 32 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» Optimizing Supreme Commander (18)
by OgreFade (150) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago
74.9% 37 Ratings
» Please rate this
Read this Media-Blog entry!» The War Widens: Supreme Commander Dual Display (14)
by DaugWok (85) Talk with this user on their Shout Box (My other blogs) Edited 75 months ago

          CLUSTER SHOUT BOX
 
 

164 User Comment(s) • 49 root comment(s)
Previous Page  Page 2 of 10Next Page
Click to view p4l1ndr0m3's User Page p4l1ndr0m3 (499)  My XFire username is: p4l1ndr0m3 Click to view p4l1ndr0m3's User Profile Talk to p4l1ndr0m3 in the Shout! Box I am an AMD Agent Mar 18, 2007 - 11:38 pm
Voting closes in 20 minutes, not 1 hour and 20 minutes right?

» Login to reply to this
Click to view BellBoy's User Page BellBoy (19)  Talk to BellBoy in the Shout! Box Mar 19, 2007 - 12:12 am
Polls closed exactly at 3:00 a.m., guess that answers your question.

Nice work all, some truly excellent submissions!

Can't wait to see the top 10.

» Login to reply to this


Click to view p4l1ndr0m3's User Page p4l1ndr0m3 (499)  My XFire username is: p4l1ndr0m3 Click to view p4l1ndr0m3's User Profile Talk to p4l1ndr0m3 in the Shout! Box I am an AMD Agent Mar 18, 2007 - 11:55 pm
5 minutes left, id assume

» Login to reply to this
Click to view p4l1ndr0m3's User Page p4l1ndr0m3 (499)  My XFire username is: p4l1ndr0m3 Talk to p4l1ndr0m3 in the Shout! Box I am an AMD Agent Mar 19, 2007 - 12:00 am
Ok, game over, time for sleep.

» Login to reply to this




Click to view BellBoy's User Page BellBoy (19)  Talk to BellBoy in the Shout! Box Mar 18, 2007 - 11:02 pm | Edited on Mar 19, 2007 - 06:13 am
Sorry for the post - it was late and I was tired.

» Login to reply to this
Click to view p4l1ndr0m3's User Page p4l1ndr0m3 (499)  My XFire username is: p4l1ndr0m3 Click to view p4l1ndr0m3's User Profile Talk to p4l1ndr0m3 in the Shout! Box I am an AMD Agent Mar 19, 2007 - 04:17 am | Edited on Mar 19, 2007 - 05:13 am
Seems that "BellBoy" has it in for me...

To your question: I'm sure firingsquad has a way to weed through the vote padding and down-voting, it would be naive to think otherwise.

If you have a problem with me or anyone else, I suggest reporting your concerns to the judges directly.
fs.feedback@firingsquad.com
That was the email they gave us in the beginning for any questions.

» Login to reply to this
Click to view BellBoy's User Page BellBoy (19)  Talk to BellBoy in the Shout! Box Mar 19, 2007 - 05:46 am | Edited on Mar 19, 2007 - 06:13 am
Sorry, double post.

» Login to reply to this



Click to view OldFriend's User Page OldFriend (178)  Click to view OldFriend's User Profile Talk to OldFriend in the Shout! Box I am an AMD Agent Mar 19, 2007 - 12:05 am | Edited on Mar 19, 2007 - 02:27 am
where did you hear that rumor?

» Login to reply to this
Click to view CanadaDave's User Page CanadaDave (303)  Talk to CanadaDave in the Shout! Box I am an AMD Agent Mar 19, 2007 - 04:35 am | Edited on Mar 19, 2007 - 08:40 am
I'd like to know that as well - I think BellBoy (who is a relative of mine, btw, and I'm really glad he deleted the comment above) was just watching the voting patterns in the last couple of hours at the end, and was frustrated at what he saw.

Though, I'll say this: I'd *REALLY* love to see a list of voters posted for each article - who voted, and what the percentages were (make the voting public, in other words - if not for this round, then for future rounds).

Public voting removes ALL abuses. Bringing people in to vote for your own article is encouraged - but having those people systematically downvote the other articles, well, that's just not cool.

Enough. It's done, we're all stressed out waiting for the responses, and tension is just too high to be debating something like this. I'd like for everyone to take out the direct references to users in their comments, ok?

Bleah. All the drama aside... congratulations to all entrants for a really well-fought round.

(Edited for clarification of points above)

» Login to reply to this
Click to view kevinSpiess's User Page kevinSpiess (156)  Click to view kevinSpiess's User Profile Talk to kevinSpiess in the Shout! Box Mar 19, 2007 - 04:27 pm
Ya, my article dropped a whopping 5%, in like, the last two hours or so of voting.

» Login to reply to this


Click to view Droniac's User Page Droniac (114)  My XFire username is: Droniac Click to view Droniac's User Profile Talk to Droniac in the Shout! Box Mar 19, 2007 - 08:43 am
Actually I thought this round was rather downvote-free! In the previous round all the scores were incredibly low - even for the absolutely amazing entries that were amongst them, because there was sooo much downvoting. This round seems a lot different, with a much higher average score. Although I did notice nearly all entries dropped several points in the final few hours, it sucks that people do that, but it's not going to affect much when just about every entry dropped some points.

Every entry this round is awesome in it's own right - and deserves a place in the next round... unfortunately only about half of us get to advance. I wonder who will get to advance, because I have absolutely no idea. I'd be hard-pressed to pick 10 people out of these entries to advance, simply because they're all so good.

» Login to reply to this


Click to view suibhne's User Page suibhne (65)  My XFire username is: suibhne Click to view suibhne's User Profile Talk to suibhne in the Shout! Box Mar 19, 2007 - 06:58 am | Edited on Mar 19, 2007 - 08:31 am
As palindrome said, pretty much everyone above 65% or 70% dropped 3-5 points last night, across the board. I wouldn't worry too much about it, particularly as the judge's scores count most heavily anyway. Unless the formula has been tweaked, in fact, judge's scores will count (relatively) more this time around than in Round 1, because the number of advancing entrants will be much smaller.

I didn't see much evidence of systemic downvoting, honestly. If someone looks only at his score, it's tempting to see this problem because it can be frustrating to watch your percentage decline - especially when you're not given much constructive feedback by readers. Looking at the whole field, though, the downward trend was pretty general.

» Login to reply to this


Click to view p4l1ndr0m3's User Page p4l1ndr0m3 (499)  My XFire username is: p4l1ndr0m3 Click to view p4l1ndr0m3's User Profile Talk to p4l1ndr0m3 in the Shout! Box I am an AMD Agent Mar 19, 2007 - 04:43 am | Edited on Mar 19, 2007 - 05:09 am
Any friend's and family that I asked to support my article by voting were also asked not to lower any of my competitor's scores. Also, I watched the last 3-4 hours of voting last night. All of the front runners, including myself, dropped 3 to 6 points or so all at once.

» Login to reply to this




Click to view chentsen's User Page chentsen (41)  Click to view chentsen's User Profile Talk to chentsen in the Shout! Box Mar 18, 2007 - 11:22 pm
did u downvote our stuff? no offense but thats messed up?

» Login to reply to this
Click to view chentsen's User Page chentsen (41)  Talk to chentsen in the Shout! Box Mar 19, 2007 - 11:19 am
Well i didn't have evidence to substantiate nor was I trying to get into a quarrel, it was just the way he worded the question was really fishy.

» Login to reply to this




Click to view p4l1ndr0m3's User Page p4l1ndr0m3 (499)  My XFire username is: p4l1ndr0m3 Click to view p4l1ndr0m3's User Profile Talk to p4l1ndr0m3 in the Shout! Box I am an AMD Agent Mar 18, 2007 - 10:02 pm
Feels like I'm stuck in Max Payne's bullet time right now...

» Login to reply to this
Click to view obsolete's User Page obsolete (29)  Click to view obsolete's User Profile Talk to obsolete in the Shout! Box Mar 18, 2007 - 10:26 pm
I'm just glad sleeping eats up a good bit of the waiting time.

» Login to reply to this
Click to view Beefysworld's User Page Beefysworld (290)  My XFire username is: beefysworld Talk to Beefysworld in the Shout! Box I am an AMD Agent Mar 19, 2007 - 12:39 am
That's easy enough for everyone else. It's only afternoon here, so I've got a long wait ahead of me...

» Login to reply to this




Click to view Beefysworld's User Page Beefysworld (290)  My XFire username is: beefysworld Click to view Beefysworld's User Profile Talk to Beefysworld in the Shout! Box I am an AMD Agent Mar 18, 2007 - 08:36 pm
» Here's an idea, DanT
As it's going to be a tough choice, how about you let the top 15 in this round, then knock out 5 after the creative round, then down to the final two last round? Keep people on their toes (and lets a few more top pieces in this round)

» Login to reply to this
Click to view OldFriend's User Page OldFriend (178)  Click to view OldFriend's User Profile Talk to OldFriend in the Shout! Box I am an AMD Agent Mar 18, 2007 - 09:06 pm | Edited on Mar 18, 2007 - 09:10 pm
not a bad idea! i swear i'll upload media of MY cat if i make it!

nervous-time folks. I normally have no problem with self-confidence, but putting your work out for the world to judge is a damn fine way to make anyone feel small. (*Napoleon Dynamite voice* Stop Looking at me!!! GAWWWWD)

» Login to reply to this
Click to view p4l1ndr0m3's User Page p4l1ndr0m3 (499)  My XFire username is: p4l1ndr0m3 Talk to p4l1ndr0m3 in the Shout! Box I am an AMD Agent Mar 18, 2007 - 10:01 pm | Edited on Mar 18, 2007 - 10:01 pm
double post

» Login to reply to this


Click to view p4l1ndr0m3's User Page p4l1ndr0m3 (499)  My XFire username is: p4l1ndr0m3 Talk to p4l1ndr0m3 in the Shout! Box I am an AMD Agent Mar 18, 2007 - 09:57 pm
get your own tots...

» Login to reply to this
Click to view OldFriend's User Page OldFriend (178)  Click to view OldFriend's User Profile Talk to OldFriend in the Shout! Box I am an AMD Agent Mar 19, 2007 - 02:26 am
didja take it off any sweet jumps yet?

» Login to reply to this





Click to view Mishkin's User Page Mishkin (30)  Click to view Mishkin's User Profile Talk to Mishkin in the Shout! Box Mar 18, 2007 - 04:04 am
24 Entries. The FEAR review can easily be eliminated because it's not adressing the topic.

so 23 then. 10 people go on. The odds aren't that bad.

» Login to reply to this


Previous Page  Page 2 of 10Next Page

POST A COMMENT

» Note: You need to be logged in to write a comment!

Login here, or if you don't have an account with FiringSquad, register here, it's FREE!

  
          CLUSTER MEMBERS (29)
 
 

GX-Warspit... (129)
Joined 75 months ago

GX-Alan (78)
Joined 75 months ago

DaugWok (85)
Joined 75 months ago

Dant (697)
CREATOR
Joined 75 months ago

Power666 (25)
Joined 75 months ago

OgreFade (150)
Joined 75 months ago

jacobvandy... (1636)
Joined 75 months ago

darrellwu (24)
Joined 75 months ago

p4l1ndr0m3 (499)
Joined 75 months ago

kadf88 (5)
Joined 75 months ago

Itchyeyes (77)
Joined 75 months ago

Droniac (114)
Joined 75 months ago

ExpertPeng... (3)
Joined 75 months ago

Swatt (25)
Joined 75 months ago

obsolete (29)
Joined 75 months ago

OldFriend (178)
Joined 75 months ago

evernight (6)
Joined 75 months ago

rados (15)
Joined 75 months ago

Palladiuma... (29)
Joined 75 months ago

CanadaDave (303)
Joined 75 months ago

suibhne (65)
Joined 75 months ago

kevinSpies... (156)
Joined 75 months ago

Mishkin (30)
Joined 75 months ago

Millroy (24)
Joined 75 months ago

chentsen (41)
Joined 75 months ago

xens (11)
Joined 75 months ago

quixilver (5)
Joined 75 months ago

Kristopher (5)
Joined 75 months ago

Fedor (19)
Joined 75 months ago